Sanjay Leela Bhansali’s ambitious project Heeramandi has taken the viewing audience by storm, featuring a star-studded cast including Manisha Koirala, Sonakshi Sinha, Aditi Rao Hydari, Sharmin Segal, Richa Chadha, and Sanjeeda Shaikh. The series, known for its grandeur and meticulous attention to detail, has been a hot topic of discussion among viewers and critics alike. Each character in Heeramandi has generated considerable buzz, but none more so than Sharmin Segal, who has been heavily critiqued for what some are calling ‘expressionless acting.’
Sharmin, who is the niece of the series’ renowned director Sanjay Leela Bhansali, finds herself at the center of a social media storm as critics accuse her of failing to deliver dynamic expressions throughout her performance. However, Heeramandi actor Anuj Sharma, who portrayed the character of Hamid, has come forward to defend her.
In an exclusive interview with The Press Free Journal, Anuj Sharma asserted, “It is not necessary to have an expression every time. Sharmin has given her 100 percent to the role. She is carrying the entire load of the series on her shoulders. It is not a small series; it’s one of the most expensive shows in Asia, directed by the world’s best director, and released worldwide. People are against her because of nepotism.”
Sharma delved deeper into the ongoing discussions about nepotism in the entertainment industry, stating, “There have been talks about nepotism for the past five years. I have been in the industry for 27 years, and my family has sacrificed a lot for my career. They have as much right to my success as I do. There’s no such thing as nepotism in this context. If you view Sharmin not as Sanjay sir’s niece but as a new, independent actor entering the industry, you will find no flaws in her work. You will love her performance. I have no problems with that.”
Adding to the discourse, Bollywood actress Richa Chadha, who also stars in Heeramandi, provided her perspective on the trolling Segal has faced. In an interview with Pinkvilla, Chadha commented, “I think truthfully, it is the audience’s right. It’s the audience’s prerogative that you like the show or dislike the show.
. You like a performance or dislike a performance.”
She added, “But in the era of social media, the culture of trolling, making memes, and harsh criticism can be hurtful for anyone. We must never be unkind because it can happen to you tomorrow. And everyone is a human being.”
Despite the mixed reactions, the fundamental success of Heeramandi remains indisputable. The series continues to captivate audiences globally with its rich narrative and highly detailed production quality, a signature of Sanjay Leela Bhansali’s creations. Yet, the backlash faced by Sharmin Segal underscores a broader issue within the entertainment industry: the pressure and scrutiny faced by those who come from established film families.
The debate on nepotism is not new and has been a subject of heated discussion for years. Many argue that individuals born into film families often have easier access to opportunities compared to outsiders, while others maintain that talent and hard work are necessary to sustain a career, regardless of one’s background. Sharma’s comments echo this sentiment, emphasizing that Sharmin’s work should be judged on its own merit, independent of her familial connections.
Moreover, the sharp rise in social media usage has intensified scrutiny, creating an environment where actors are subject to immediate and often severe public judgment. Platforms like Twitter, Instagram, and Facebook enable audiences to voice their opinions instantaneously, contributing both to the democratization of critique and the rise of cyberbullying. As Chadha mentioned, this can be profoundly impactful on an individual’s emotional well-being.
With Heeramandi continuing its successful run, the conversation around Sharmin Segal’s performance and the broader implications of nepotism and social media criticism are likely to persist. While some viewers might remain critical, others may come to appreciate the nuances in her portrayal as they engage more deeply with the character and the storyline.
In the end, Anuj Sharma’s and Richa Chadha’s defense of Sharmin Segal serves as a reminder of the importance of compassion and fairness in the public discourse surrounding entertainment. As audiences, the responsibility lies with us to offer constructive criticism and support the creative efforts that bring such expansive and culturally rich stories to our screens.
The DNA app is now available for download on the Google Play Store. Please download the app and share your feedback with us.
